The Pro-Human Assembly and Mr Trump’s flurry of posts on the subject came less than a week after the public resignation of Jacob Coxon, a researcher at Anthropic, an AI firm. Mr Coxon said that he and his colleagues believed that AI could “kill us all” by the end of the decade, a message that he promptly delivered across prime-time television. Another top scientist at the firm put the probability of extinction at more than 10%. That has made many politicians sit up. But despite the mixed politics of the Pro-Human Assembly, a partisan divide remains. Hakeem Jeffries and Chuck Schumer, the Democratic leaders in the House and Senate, respectively, called for urgent action. Mike Johnson, the Republican speaker of the House, warned against hasty regulation. “If Congress just races in and does some sort of emergency session to try to regulate AI,” said Mr Johnson, “we will lose the race to China”. AI labs, he argued, should “self-police”. In general, polls show that Americans disagree: eight in ten say they support regulation, even if it slows down innovation. The trickier question is what that regulation should be. To date most activity has been in states. Last September Gavin Newsom, California’s governor, signed a law requiring AI firms to report safety incidents within 15 days, on pain of up to $1m in penalties. Three months later Kathy Hochul, New York’s governor, signed a law demanding faster disclosure and imposing larger fines. Both laws would have been bolder, with higher penalties and exposing firms to more liability, were it not for opposition from the likes of Leading the Future, a super PAC whose supporters include Greg Brockman, a founder of OpenAI, another firm. Clear gaps in state laws remain. California’s law did not apply to the now-notorious Hugging Face incident, when OpenAI’s agents went rogue, because it occurred in an “evaluation phase” designed to elicit bad behaviour. If proponents of federal regulation want to secure bipartisan support, they may have to compromise in two areas, argues Brad Carson, the co-founder of Public First Action, which advocates for AI regulation and is backed by Anthropic. One is how easy it is for the government to shut down an errant model. A second is whether bills should cover only existential risks, such as AI models’ ability to create biological weapons, or also include issues such as liability and children’s use of chatbots.
But federal lawmakers have a hodgepodge of proposals. Mr Sanders and Mr Casar want a ban on any vaguely defined “superintelligent” AI. One bill in the House would require that AI firms use third-party evaluators for their models and allow the commerce department to suspend those posing imminent “catastrophic” risk; in an attempt to give structure to dread, the bill defines “catastrophic” as the death of more than 50 people or damages of at least $1bn. A separate AI Safety Bill being negotiated in the Senate by John Thune, the Republican leader, Ted Cruz, a Republican senator, and Amy Klobuchar, a Democratic one, is thought to let the government seek a court order to ban models from being released in the first place. The toughest bill, from Josh Hawley, a Republican senator, and Richard Blumenthal, a Democrat, would force developers to submit AI models to the government for testing. Even within the administration, there have been mixed messages. On September 15th, the day after Mr Trump dubbed attempts to curb AI a “SICK conspiracy”, J.D. Vance, the vice-president, said that AI firms “building Frankenstein…should stop” unilaterally. Firms would likely need an antitrust waiver to co-ordinate such a pause without fear of prosecution. The Democrats’ debate contains its own contradictions. On September 14th Barack Obama, a former president, Kamala Harris, a former vice-president and presidential nominee, and Nancy Pelosi, a former House speaker, all endorsed Project Blueprint, an initiative to rebuild ties between the technology industry and Democrats, and to promote what Ms Harris called “sensible” oversight. However, it is bankrolled by Ron Conway, a venture capitalist who has also supported Leading the Future, the super PAC which helped water down state regulations. On paper, many AI firms back some sort of regulation. Anthropic, the most enthusiastic, has cited the Federal Aviation Administration and Food and Drug Administration as models; in the meantime, it has said it would embed third-party evaluators in its lab, a practice that competitors claim they will follow. Google has suggested a body setting industry standards, modelled on the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority. But no lab has thrown its heft behind any of the big state or federal proposals in full, with the exception of Anthropic’s support for California’s law.
Voters’ patience for “sensible” regulation may wear thin. AI is already featuring heavily in the midterm elections this year. As the campaign for the presidency ramps up, after November, candidates’ positions may harden. “I predict to you every single Democratic candidate who runs in 2028 is going to be for a pause of some kind,” says Mr Carson. However, the next president will not take office until 2029. Any rules in the interim would need to be agreed by Congress and Mr Trump. While politicians debate, the models will evolve.■ Stay on top of American politics with The US in brief, our daily newsletter with fast analysis of the most important political news, and Checks and Balance, a weekly note that examines the state of American democracy and the issues that matter to voters. This article was downloaded by zlibrary from https://www.economist.com/united-states/2026/09/17/the-debate-over-ai-has-taken- over-washington
Donald Trump’s attacks on postal voting are failing But he has other ways to snarl the midterm elections Sep 17th 2026 Jamie Shew, the chief election officer in Douglas County, Kansas, took queries recently from anxious counterparts in other counties: did he have a barcode guy? His is the only county, out of 105 in Kansas, that prints unique barcodes on all postal-ballot envelopes. That put him in compliance with a rule issued last month by the United States Postal Service (USPS). His colleagues feared they had just a few weeks to follow suit before sending out ballots for the midterms in November. Election officials in Democratic and Republican states alike were calling the rule unworkable. On September 14th the Supreme Court came to the rescue and blocked it, although it had been drafted at the direction of Donald Trump. Despite availing himself of it, the president despises mail voting, a method more
commonly used by Democrats than Republicans and one he claims, without evidence, is rife with fraud. In an executive order in March he tried to turn the USPS from a mere courier into an arbiter of who gets to vote by post. Instead, the president’s bid to intervene in the midterms met the same fate as his other attempts which—by executive order, lawsuits and proposed legislation—have sought to reshape how Americans vote. None has held up. But the president has sown confusion and created a scapegoat if Republicans lose the House or Senate this November. The proposed rule would have added a convoluted and untested requirement that the USPS must check envelope barcodes against state voter lists uploaded to an online portal that does not yet exist. Election officials warned of widespread delays and disenfranchisement. USPS employees, a whistleblower wrote to Democratic senators, considered the system a “shit show”. With less colourful language, and only two justices openly dissenting, the Supreme Court’s order this week blocked Mr Trump’s manoeuvre. In a full legal proceeding, the justices wrote, Mr Trump is likely to lose “on the merits”. The order cited the USPS’s slapdash rulemaking and the disruption that would probably follow as reasons to maintain the status quo for now.
The president appears out of options to change voting rules before November. That does not stop other machinations. Three worries predominate: that the president might send federal officers to the polls to intimidate voters, order police to seize ballot boxes, or pressure MAGA- friendly election administrators to refuse to certify results. State officials, Democratic congressmen and litigation non-profits have been war-gaming those scenarios for months. Senate Democrats have been holding tabletop exercises with outside advisers, including Eric Holder, a former attorney-general. Justin Vail of Protect Democracy, one of the organisations involved, says the first imperative is to go to court immediately in any such incident. The work involves training county clerks, the first port of call for poll workers. Meanwhile, election officials must convince voters that postal ballots are reliable. When Kansas held primaries, in-person early voting shot up in Mr Shew’s county. A fifth of the increase came from people who had previously voted by mail. ■ Stay on top of American politics with The US in brief, our daily newsletter with fast analysis of the most important political news, and Checks and Balance, a weekly note that examines the state of American democracy and the issues that matter to voters. This article was downloaded by zlibrary from https://www.economist.com/united-states/2026/09/17/donald-trumps-attacks-on-postal- voting-are-failing
How House Republicans might fend off defeat A polling error and a few good breaks could be enough Sep 17th 2026 In the age of Donald Trump, beware of sure things. Democrats are favourites to take back the House of Representatives on November 3rd. Opposition parties have historically done well in midterms, and Mr Trump’s unpopularity, persistent inflation and the Iran war have created a particularly poisonous environment for Republicans. The Economist’s election forecast model rates Democrats’ chances at 92%, and prediction markets are nearly as confident. Yet events predicted to occur only one time out of ten do nonetheless occur, and Mr Trump and his MAGA faithful have outperformed polls often enough since 2016 to give pause. By what path could Republicans defy the odds and hold the House?