All 435 districts are up for re-election, with Democrats needing a net gain of just three seats to win the chamber. But a burst of gerrymandering has made that harder. Conventionally, states redraw their districts once a decade, after a census, but Mr Trump urged Republican-led states to gerrymander ahead of the midterms. Despite Democratic countermoves, the president’s push has succeeded, with redistricting adding around eight seats to the Republicans’ total, according to our model. (They would have secured nine, if the Supreme Court had not blocked their proposal for a new map in Missouri on September 10th.) Without this gambit, protecting the House would look nigh-on impossible. “If we hold the House it’s going to be because of the mid-decade redistricting,” says Jason Roe, a strategist working for Tom Barrett, a Republican congressman in a tight race in Michigan. “I didn’t agree with it, but it created a result.” This rush of redistricting—after decades of gerrymandering and Americans’ habit of moving near like-minded voters—means that just 5-10% of House seats are competitive. A few factors may swing in Republicans’ favour. The first is polling error. When pollsters ask voters which party’s candidate they would support, if the election were held today, Democrats lead by an average of 6.7 points. If a margin that big materialises on election day,
Democrats will take the House comfortably. But even assuming no big shift in those numbers by November, a polling error similar to the one in 2020, when the congressional vote for Democrats came in about five points lower than in late generic polls, would make Republicans heavy favourites to win the House. Factors that are always important—turnout, the quality of candidates and a surge in negative advertising—would then figure even more significantly. Consider the toss-up races in Pennsylvania, a battleground state that broke Democrats’ hearts in 2024. In the swingy 8th House district, in the north- east of the state, Mr Trump won the presidential vote by 8.5 points in 2024. Rob Bresnahan, the Republican who flipped the House seat that year, won by just 1.5 points. Two years earlier, Josh Shapiro, the state’s moderate Democratic governor, won the district by ten points. What explains this particular electorate’s swings? “I think people vote more for the person than the party,” says Paige Cognetti, the mayor of Scranton, the district’s largest city, who is running to take back Mr Bresnahan’s seat. Ms Cognetti entered politics as an anti-corruption campaigner. On the stump, she points out that Mr Bresnahan made more than 600 stock trades in 2025 and may have profited from inside information. Mr Bresnahan denies wrongdoing. Ms Cognetti sees a link between her message and Mr Trump’s original pitch to “drain the swamp”. She understands “why they have wanted to send somebody to Washington to clean things up”. At minus 25 points, Mr Trump’s net approval rating is so low, and his insistence on being the election’s main character so loud, that he exerts a heavy drag on vulnerable incumbents like Mr Bresnahan. In Pennsylvania’s closely fought 10th district, Scott Perry, the Republican office-holder, is a member of the right-wing House Freedom Caucus who “can’t hide” from Mr Trump, says Christopher Borick, a political scientist at Lehigh University. “I don’t know that he even wants to hide.” With no alternative, Republicans have bet on mobilising Mr Trump’s still-enthusiastic base, painting Democrats as extremists. It would help if Mr Trump’s broader popularity improves. This is conceivable if, for instance, the war with Iran ends. A Democratic campaign strategist in Pennsylvania, J.J. Abbott, recalls watching with dismay in 2024 as Mr Trump’s polling in battleground states
ticked up steadily as the election neared. “That’s one lesson for Democrats: they should not assume his numbers can’t move in a positive direction,” he says. Republican chances to hold the chamber are at 10% and not 1% for plausible reasons. And Americans have seen Mr Trump’s Houdini act before.■ Stay on top of American politics with The US in brief, our daily newsletter with fast analysis of the most important political news, and Checks and Balance, a weekly note that examines the state of American democracy and the issues that matter to voters. This article was downloaded by zlibrary from https://www.economist.com/united-states/2026/09/16/how-house-republicans-might- fend-off-defeat
Pro-family proposals offer a glimpse at a post- Trump agenda Conservative policy circles are mulling ideas to support two-parent households Sep 17th 2026 The vice-president’s views on families make him a hero to many Americans on the right and a ticking-time bomb to those on the left, wary of his opinions becoming national policy. Over the years J.D. Vance has criticised no-fault divorce and suggested that parents with children should have “more power” at the polls. “Normal Americans”, he has asserted, “want a family policy that doesn’t shunt their kids into crap day care”. It was no surprise, then, when a small furore erupted this month after the New York Times reported that the White House would extend federal funds for families with children in day care to stay-at-home parents. Though the White House called the report “baseless speculation”, Rosa DeLauro, a
Democratic congresswoman, was among those to condemn the idea, arguing that it would “force more parents to compete for the same inadequate pot of money” and “disproportionately hurt single working parents”. Rachel Campos-Duffy, a Fox News presenter, praised the proposal. “I call it putting families first.” The episode offered a glimpse of a coming fight. A growing number of conservative politicians, staffers and think-tankers are backing not just a pronatalist agenda, to encourage Americans to have babies, but a “pro- family” one, to make it easier to raise them. Ideas range from those popular with Democrats to those explicitly favouring married, heterosexual couples. Donald Trump may advance a few proposals in the remainder of his term, but the debate will almost certainly be elevated by those trying to succeed him. Historically, Republicans have feared mothers living off the state; that’s one reason that America lacks federal paid maternity leave. To date, the Trump administration’s most direct policy change for American families has been to limit eligibility for health insurance and cut food stamps. At least 1.2m children have lost access so far, through the One Big Beautiful Bill Act (OBBBA) passed last year. Nevertheless, argues Brad Wilcox of the Institute for Family Studies, a think-tank, there is a generational shift among Republican politicians and their staffers, who are keen to advance social policies beyond restricting abortion. “Middle-aged and older Republicans and conservatives tend to be very sceptical,” Mr Wilcox says, of “real effort to advance family policy”. But younger Republicans are more willing to offer support for families, concerned by the falling birth rate and their interest in serving the party’s new base. “President Trump won with the support of working people with kids,” Josh Hawley, a Missouri senator, said in 2024 when he proposed increasing the child tax credit. The tax bill “should provide them a big tax cut”. Marco Rubio, the secretary of state, and Mr Vance have also endorsed expanding child tax credits, with Mr Vance telling the anti-abortion movement to be “pro-family and pro-life in the fullest sense”.
Expanding tax credits for families with children is a standard Democratic priority; OBBBA did so modestly. One bipartisan bill, introduced in May, would give a baby bonus to help cover the costs of having a newborn. However other proposals are distinctly conservative. In addition to expanding support for families with a stay-at-home parent, another priority is scrapping any “marriage penalties” in the tax code; combining incomes through marriage risks disqualifying a couple from receiving federal benefits. For critics on the left, there are a few problems. These include that “expanding” access to support can mean expanding the pool of people eligible for it, as the reported White House proposal does, without making more cash available. Democrats prefer more money for universal child care. Another, related problem is that some proposals are designed to reward only certain types of families. In January the Heritage Foundation, the conservative think-tank that published Project 2025, released a 70,000 word manifesto. Labelled the “Manhattan Project” of family policy, it endorses now-standard Democratic priorities, such as doubling the child tax credit for under-fours and loosening rules for building new homes. However, Heritage also laid out that marriage is “the committed union of one man and one woman” and says policies should favour “natural marriage over same-sex and polyamorous relationships, cohabitation, or intentional single parenthood”. Its proposal bemoans no-fault divorce and includes more benefits for those who marry young, have more children and stay at home. It is an effort to “reframe the entire conversation”, says Emma Waters, one of its authors. At a pro-family Heritage event earlier this year Jennifer Galardi, an analyst at the foundation, asked a panel if men with families should be paid more than women, remarking, “as the culture shifts, I am hoping that window…opens”. Another panellist pointed out that this change would be illegal. The pro-family movement contains a spectrum of views. No one in the Trump administration has yet endorsed the Heritage plan. Patrick Brown of the Ethics and Public Policy Centre, another conservative think-tank, says he would not support the reported White House proposal for stay-at-home
parents. In general, though, Mr Brown is encouraged. It is just easy to see how an administration being led by secretary Rubio or vice-president Vance, he says, would “really put more effort into the pro-family stuff.” He and his peers have an agenda ready if they do. ■ Stay on top of American politics with The US in brief, our daily newsletter with fast analysis of the most important political news, and Checks and Balance, a weekly note that examines the state of American democracy and the issues that matter to voters. This article was downloaded by zlibrary from https://www.economist.com/united-states/2026/09/17/pro-family-proposals-offer-a- glimpse-at-a-post-trump-agenda
Developers are learning to love Zohran Mamdani New York’s socialist mayor wants a housing boom Sep 17th 2026 BACK IN FEBRUARY, the new mayor of New York City went to Washington. Zohran Mamdani, a Democratic Socialist, was lobbying Donald Trump for $21bn in federal funding. The money was not for universal child care or another lefty passion, but for Sunnyside Yard, a colossal housing development in Queens. The project had been delayed for years—back in 2019 Alexandria Ocasio Cortez, a New York congresswoman and another member of the Democratic Socialists of America (DSA), opposed the proposal, saying such building “displaces communities of colour and parcels off public land to private real- estate developers”. But now Mr Mamdani was on board. A photo showed him and Mr Trump smiling in the Oval Office, with the president