tax, may need a trust fund to help local governments. In 2026, Florida has become America’s most important red state. If these midterms have taught America anything, though, it is that no politics are permanent.■ Stay on top of American politics with The US in brief, our daily newsletter with fast analysis of the most important political news, and Checks and Balance, a weekly note that examines the state of American democracy and the issues that matter to voters. This article was downloaded by zlibrary from https://www.economist.com/united-states/2026/11/12/how-florida-withstood-a-blue- wave
An emerging consensus on trans politics Voters want neither trans kids playing girls’ sports, nor politicians obsessed with it Nov 12th 2026 The most effective Republican ad of 2024, many strategists agreed, was one that declared that “Kamala is for they/them” and Donald Trump was “for you”. This year, conservative groups tried to repeat the trick, devoting at least $183m to attack ads on transgender issues, according to AdImpact, a research firm. The strategy failed to protect Republican seats. Yet where trans-related issues were put to voters directly, the response was different. Four states considered ballot measures to restrict girls’ and women’s sports to biological females. All passed, including in solidly Democratic states. That points to a new phase in the fight over trans rights. A growing share of voters don’t want trans kids playing girls’ sports. Nor do they want politicians to focus on the issue.
Two-thirds of Americans favour laws requiring athletes to play on teams that match their sex at birth, up from 58% in 2022, according to the Pew Research Centre. Around 30 states already have rules on trans athletes. In June the Supreme Court upheld such policies. Some 59% of adults approved of that ruling, almost twice the share who disapproved. Though all the ballot measures this year concerned gender and sports, the specifics of the initiatives in Arizona, Colorado, Nebraska and Washington varied. Arizona’s includes requirements that trans people use bathrooms at schools and sports facilities that match their sex at birth. Washington’s measure, passed by a 12-point margin, requires medical documentation to verify sex for each child seeking to play girls’ sports. Even as a majority opinion emerges on trans sports, it is a deciding issue for vanishingly few Americans. In Washington state, the trans measure passed despite Democratic congressional candidates winning nearly two-thirds of the statewide vote. A poll by AP-NORC in October found that just 11% of voters considered trans issues a top priority. “After 2024 voters really thought that Democrats were overly preoccupied with these ‘social issues’,” says Tré Easton of Searchlight Institute, a Democrat-aligned think-tank. In this election, with voters concerned about affordability, it was Republicans who were caught in their own culture-war traps. In a sign of shifting politics, James Talarico, the incoming Democratic senator from Texas, once called God “non-binary” but said during his campaign that he opposes “trans athletes playing in girls’ sports if it endangers safety or fairness.” Sherrod Brown, Ohio’s Senator-elect, took out his own ads in response to Republicans’ trans attacks during the campaign. “With everything going on,” his ads asked, “that’s what they are talking about?”■ Stay on top of American politics with The US in brief, our daily newsletter with fast analysis of the most important political news, and Checks and Balance, a weekly note that examines the state of American democracy and the issues that matter to voters.
This article was downloaded by zlibrary from https://www.economist.com/united-states/2026/11/12/an-emerging-consensus-on-trans-
The fight over Republicans’ future has begun After a staggering loss, the party is battling over whom to blame and how to move forward Nov 12th 2026 AS THE DIRE results came in on November 3rd, young Republicans at Butterworth’s, a MAGA haunt a stone’s throw from the Capitol in Washington, sipped glumly on cocktails such as the “Senate Majority Martini” and “The Red Wave”. “This is historic”, noted one, “in the same way the Hindenburg was historic.” Donald Trump has commandeered the Republican party for over a decade. It is now adrift, with developments since the election only adding to the confusion. On Capitol Hill, Republicans are moving in different directions. On November 10th House Republicans elected as their leader Jim Jordan of Ohio, a co-founder of the hard-right Freedom Caucus who sought to overturn Joe Biden’s election in 2020. In contrast, John Thune of South
Dakota, a veteran senator who has clashed with President Trump, was easily re-elected as the party’s leader in the upper chamber, despite efforts by more right-wing lawmakers to delay that election. The Nvidia scandal adds further uncertainty; the party is only beginning to grapple with questions of how the administration handled intelligence that Jensen Huang, Nvidia’s boss, was having an affair with an alleged spy. The president’s support of artificial intelligence had become a divisive issue among Republicans, even before this scandal erupted over the industry’s most important executive. Mr Trump’s dominance of the party has for years papered over its fissures. They are now being laid bare. The president himself remains defiant. On November 6th Mr Trump told CBS that his deportation drive had been “too tough” and that he was open to a deal on immigration with Democrats. An hour later, as if to declare himself the most MAGA of all, he appointed Stephen Miller, a nationalist and immigration hardliner who spearheaded that drive, as his new chief of staff. Within MAGA, loyalists to the president remain. Sarah Huckabee Sanders, the governor of Arkansas, was among those to parrot Mr Trump’s line that he was not on the ballot: “I don’t think that this can be a line drawn against him.” A few MAGA media figures, namely Mark Levin and Laura Loomer, continue to support the Iran war and America’s relationship with Israel. Yet all this compounds problems for the president, who is already vulnerable to critics blaming the midterm loss on his policies and hubris. Since the election a noisy group of MAGA purists have contended that Mr Trump let the movement down. On November 4th J.D. Vance, Mr Trump’s vice- president, did not blame Mr Trump by name, but took the stunning step of blaming his boss’s policies, including the war, a failure to lower costs and the relationship with Israel. MAGA-purist vodcasters such as Tucker Carlson and Steve Bannon had already broken with Mr Trump over the war before the election; they were scathing after it. On November 5th Natalie Winters, the co-host of Mr Bannon’s “War Room” show, alleged that White House officials such as Howard Lutnick, the commerce secretary, had made “shady deals” and that
“the actual grifters in the administration” were tarnishing “the entire MAGA movement”. She stopped short of implicating the president. Mr Carlson called the results a “disaster”, on his show on November 4th. “You could mark it on your calendar,” he added: “Trumpism gone.” He blames war, corruption (Mr Trump was “vain and venal”) and the president’s decision to endorse flawed candidates. The administration had been too focused on fighting anti-Semitism, he argued, a stance he dubbed “Jewish lives matter”. Mr Levin, for his part, skewered Mr Carlson as a “loathsome creature” who had worked to “sabotage the president, the GOP and the midterm elections”. As brawls continue within MAGA, Republicans’ old guard, severely diminished but still defiant, is hoping for a resurrection. “The American people have rejected our party’s shift toward economic populism,” asserted Mike Pence, Mr Trump’s vice-president in his first term, in an op-ed in the Wall Street Journal, glossing over the populism espoused by many Democratic candidates. Mitt Romney, the last pre-Trump Republican to have run for president, in 2012, offered a more sweeping critique on X, pointing to the war and corruption, as well as Mr Trump’s “weaponised justice, ICE brutality, mountainous deficits, hiding Epstein, abandoning allies and coddling enemies”. Between the MAGA purists and the old guard is a more fluid category of Republican, who could be charitably called pragmatists. Ron DeSantis, the term-limited governor of Florida, failed to win the Republican presidential nomination in 2024. He now hopes the MAGA movement might give him a second look. Consider Ted Cruz, who after Tuesday’s sweep is poised to be the last remaining Republican statewide office-holder standing in Texas. In his own election autopsy on his podcast, he paid lip service to the need to rebuild as a “true blue-collar party”, but pointed to a pre-Trump solution: Republicans had to be “real free-market conservatives”. Mr Cruz, a long-standing proponent of muscular foreign policy who once cheered on Mr Trump’s war, felt compelled to change tack after the election, saying that the war should have been “brief, decisive and over”.
More fights will break out. Even as Mr Vance appeals to the MAGA purists, many within the MAGAverse despise him, not least for his ties to Silicon Valley, where he worked before running for Senate. MAGA purists are vehemently opposed to the conflict in Iran, championed by Pete Hegseth, the secretary of war, who narrowly avoided impeachment on November 10th. Yet Mr Hegseth’s purge of supposedly woke generals from the Pentagon has earned him ardent fans within the right-wing “manosphere”. The most explosive argument may be over Nvidia. Republican hawks had opposed Mr Trump’s decision, after being lobbied by Mr Huang, to ease export restrictions of Nvidia chips to China. On November 9th Mr Bannon repeated his allegation that Mr Huang is himself a spy. More battles will emerge over why the White House did not respond to a classified report from Marco Rubio, Mr Trump’s secretary of state, warning that Mr Huang’s mistress might be a Chinese spy, alongside concerns over why Mr Lutnick failed to keep America’s advanced chips from China. The election is over. The Republican brawl is just beginning.■ Stay on top of American politics with The US in brief, our daily newsletter with fast analysis of the most important political news, and Checks and Balance, a weekly note that examines the state of American democracy and the issues that matter to voters. This article was downloaded by zlibrary from https://www.economist.com/united-states/2026/11/08/the-fight-over-republicans- future-has-begun