England’s new ban on kinky porn will misfire Bans make moralists feel good, but will not work as planned Nov 5th 2026 Pornography depicting strangulation, suffocation, incest and actors pretending to be underage will be banned in England and Wales from November 6th. Few will publicly mourn the loss of videos with titles such as “Choking gets her off”. But free expression means nothing if it does not apply to that which is objectionable. The government argues that porn is causing real harm, by teaching young people that dangerous practices are not merely normal during sex but expected. It notes with shock a sharp rise in “choking”. In America, Australia and Britain roughly half of sexually active 18- to 35-year-olds report having experienced this; a generation ago it was so niche that pollsters did not bother to ask about it. Mostly it is young men choking young women; sometimes, alarmingly, without prior consent.
For many worried parents, that ends the argument. But reality is muddier than the simple morality tale told by anti-porn campaigners. “Choking” refers to a range of acts, including light pressure on the neck, that some consenting adults find pleasurable. Evidence that porn is what made it so widespread is weak. Young people hear about sex from a variety of sources, including their peers. Under-18s in Britain are already barred from accessing porn sites, but tech-savvy ones have found ways round the age-verification system—and will find ways round the new ban, too. The idea that the young can be prevented from hearing about kinks is implausible. Some of the acts whose depiction the government is forbidding are so popular that they appear in pop lyrics. Doja Cat, an American rapper with more than 50m monthly listeners on Spotify, offers lyrics such as: “Spank me, slap me, choke me.” Restrictions on free speech should be rare, narrow and clearly defined. No one doubts that governments should ban child pornography, and that this ban should be vigorously enforced. But in general people should be allowed to film acts that are legal, even if many voters find them repulsive. Britain’s new law fails the test. It is both broad and unhelpfully vague. The government has not defined the acts that will be illegal to depict. Instead it expects courts to decide on a case-by-case basis. But Britain’s overburdened state will find it hard to police the many difficult-to-judge edge cases that will emerge. In an industry enamoured with terms like “mummy” and “daddy”, how will judges be able to decide what constitutes a depiction of incest? What about whether a hand on a consenting adult’s neck constitutes strangulation? Or when fellatio crosses the line into suffocation? Courts have many more important things to do than to debate such matters, including hearing cases of actual sexual assault. Since possession of banned content is punishable by up to two years in prison, the new rules will also dilute what it means to be a sex offender. Such an important label loses value when it can be applied both to paedophiles and those harbouring a stepmum fantasy. Rather than trying ineffectually to prevent the young from learning about risky acts, governments should be ensuring that they are taught about safety,
consent and how to talk frankly to prospective partners about what the other person does and does not want. Sex education in most countries is dismal. In Britain it is better, but still has room for improvement. If children do not learn about sex and relationships from reliable sources, they will depend on unreliable ones. Pornography is an unpopular thing to defend. But Britain has become too willing to ban anything pearl-clutchers dislike, from plastic straws to noisy protests. A ban on kinky porn may please moralists, but it should alarm anyone who cares about freedom of speech or government overreach. ■ This article was downloaded by zlibrary from https://www.economist.com/leaders/2026/11/05/englands-new-ban-on-kinky-porn-will- misfire
LLMs v palaeontology Also this week, publications, film critics, preparing for emergencies, London traditions, accounting Nov 5th 2026 Letters are welcome via email to letters@economist.comFind out more about how we process your letter I work for an AI lab as a scientist and read your piece on how AI companies are not merely providing a tool for discovery but choosing to wield it themselves (“A scientific revolution”, October 17th). My field of palaeontology uses large language models to investigate the evolution of fossils by mining the formal descriptions of species from literature that often extends back to the 18th century. How fossils are formally described (their taxonomy) is key to their identification and use. The trouble is that LLMs are not good at understanding very old literature and how terminology, measurement and concepts of species and evolution
have changed over two centuries. This means an enormous amount of work for human scientists in cleaning the data before the LLM can be put to work. It’s the same for other descriptive, observational sciences like botany and zoology, where written descriptions and evidence are a big part of the accumulated knowledge of humanity codified in legacy scientific literature. The truth is that the low hanging fruit of AI, the high-quality data already in number form, collected recently in genomics and physics, is easy, but human elbow grease is what will lubricate the older sciences. Mike StephensonVisiting professor in palaeontologyNanjing University “Stop the slop” (October 17th) reports that roughly 90% of papers submitted to “predatory journals” are AI-generated. However, you characterise these journals simply as being “where authors pay for publication”. There is a brief but critical distinction. Publication fees are neither exclusive to predatory outlets nor inherent to open-access publishing. Many reputable subscription and open-access journals, including those published by non- profit learned societies such as the Federation of European Biochemical Societies, charge legitimate processing or page fees to cover operational costs and support the scientific community. The defining issue is not that authors pay, but whether rigorous peer review and high-quality editorial oversight are provided in return. Dietmar MansteinEditorFEBS LettersHanover, Germany “Are film critics as snooty and out of touch as people think?”, you ask (October 24th). You confuse subjective opinion with objective fact. Neither ten nor 1,000 subjective opinions that agree with one another add up to one objective judgment. So when you say we should “pity the reviewer” who dismissed “Citizen Kane” as “well-intentioned, muddled, amateurish” you tacitly assume that an objective review is possible, implying that any review that does not conform to expert opinion is wrong. Naturally, the great and good in every field like to think their judgments are more informed or even just better than those of hoi polloi. What they have to say may well be more informative and interesting than Kev’s waffle down the pub. But at the end of the day their remarks are just as subjective.
As for “Citizen Kane”, context is everything, especially considering what other films were being made more than 80 years ago. I could never see what all the fuss was about. Patrick PowellSt Breward, Cornwall Thank you for drawing attention to Britain’s preparedness for major emergencies and conflict (“Dad’s Army returns”, October 17th). However, the image you presented of a large, uniformed civil-aid corps undermines the principle of a whole-society approach. Berets, ranks and bands may appeal to some volunteers, but they reinforce a notion of civil defence as an eccentric, quasi-military pursuit. Moreover, building preparedness around a centrally directed corps reproduces the very dependencies that a resilient society must be able to withstand. Major, cascading emergencies, such as natural hazards, infrastructure failures or armed attacks, disrupt communications, transport, leadership and logistics. An organisation dependent on those systems will struggle precisely when it is most needed. Whole-society resilience starts with different questions. What can continue to function when organised assistance is unavailable? Can households meet their essential needs without immediate outside help? Can neighbours support one another? This approach recognises the strengths already present in communities. Practical skills, professional expertise and local knowledge exist far beyond the organisations formally designated to respond. Adults who are able to do so should be encouraged and equipped to take responsibility for themselves and those around them. Dr Frank LongGeneral secretaryInstitute of Civil Protection and Emergency ManagementCamberley, Surrey
Here at All Hallows by the Tower (the oldest church in the City of London dating from 675AD) we have our share of the “lovely nonsense” of traditions (“Standing on ceremony”, October 17th). One dates from 1380 and involves paying an annual fine of one red rose to the Lord or Lady Mayor on a velvet cushion. On Ascension Day we “beat the bounds” of the parish to demonstrate where our boundaries lie. Given that we proudly stand next to the Tower of London this involves a ceremonial skirmish with the resplendently dressed, and splendidly armed, Beefeaters. As the sides meet, much bellowing, roaring and stick waving ensues, typically in front of many bemused tourists. But no blood is spilt and both sides retire with honours. Nonsense? Absolutely not. It’s a reminder that the Church of England gives everyone in its land a place to worship, be baptised, married or buried. Lovely? Absolutely. Reverend Nicol KinradeVicar of All Hallows by the TowerLondon Schumpeter (October 17th) did an excellent job of describing the convoluted financial reporting of AI firms. It reminded me of Charlie Munger, a former vice-chairman of Berkshire Hathaway, who dismissed EBITDA as “bullshit earnings”. If he were alive today, he might well create a more suitable label, like “totally made-up bullshit earnings”.
Scott SimmonsHighlands Ranch, Colorado This article was downloaded by zlibrary from https://www.economist.com/letters/2026/11/05/llms-v-palaeontology
Divided government in America will mean more spending, not less Markets are pushing electrification. Governments must push harder
Divided government in America will mean more spending, not less But Democrats will struggle to unwind the president’s agenda, writes Tomas Philipson Nov 5th 2026 THE RESULT of America’s midterm elections occurred under two sets of conflicting facts: by many conventional measures the economy is performing above average, yet Americans remain deeply dissatisfied with their economic circumstances, displaying attitudes in surveys more typical of those during a recession. And America is far from being in that predicament. Real GDP grew at a healthy 3.4% annual rate in the third quarter, up from 2.2% in the second. Unemployment and layoffs are low and the roaring expansion in investment, partly thanks to an AI sector free from excessive regulation, offers reasons for optimism about future productivity. Yet the University of Michigan’s