road accidents or medical side-effects regulators help avert. But hardly anyone thinks the optimal amount of regulation in these areas is none at all. The world has, mercifully, so far avoided an AI Chernobyl. No lives and no real money were lost in the Hugging Face attack, the most concerning to have come to light. But the odds of disaster are shortening. In a few months open models could be as capable as Anthropic’s Mythos, the first to be seriously adept at hacking. If politicians wait for a catastrophe before writing the rules, the ones they draft in haste in its aftermath are likely to be poor. Plenty of bad ideas are already out there, from data-centre moratoriums to Bernie Sanders’s “superintelligence ban”. And bad laws may be just the start: the terrorist attacks of September 11th 2001 inspired a rethink of aviation safety but also two long wars. What might wise AI regulation look like? The goal cannot be to stymie technological advances altogether. That would indeed cause democratic America to cede the frontier to authoritarian China, and forgo remarkable scientific and economic opportunities. Making AI labs lock up their cleverer models indefinitely, even if they could be contained, could create a dangerous gap between them and everyone else. Instead, America should mandate that advanced models be thoroughly tested and, if necessary, held back until they have safeguards to block dangerous use-cases, like building bioweapons. Companies must be required to report safety incidents and whistleblowers who do so in their stead granted protection. Independent evaluators should be embedded with major labs, just as bank examiners are with lenders. Some of these ideas were hinted at in the voluntary pledges that Mr Trump recently coaxed out of the big AI firms. They should be spelled out and made mandatory. By signalling that it is serious about regulating AI, America would also foster international co-operation, particularly with China. As the models advance, so must the rules. “Let it rip” is a dead end. ■ This article was downloaded by zlibrary from https://www.economist.com/leaders/2026/10/08/a-no-rules-approach-to-ai-is-mad- politics-and-worse-policy
Britain’s Greens have voted, shamefully, to say Zionism is racism It is a damning moment for a political party with pretensions to power Oct 8th 2026 EARLIER THIS year Britain’s Green Party polled at 21%, ahead of both the Conservatives and Labour. Since Andy Burnham became prime minister, the party has lost about half its support. At their recent conference the Greens voted decisively to define Zionism as racism. The party thereby deserves to fade back into irrelevance. As well as calling Zionism racist, the new policy urges the destruction of Israel. Jews can instead live as full citizens in a Palestinian state if they choose. It endorses Palestinian violence and demands the release of “prisoners of conscience”.
Many of the party’s Jewish members feel threatened. Almost all British synagogues support the idea that Jews should have a state. Freedom of worship is a fundamental right, but they fear that their devotion will lead to them being branded racist. Greens for Palestine argue that Jews are colonists, like whites in South Africa or the pieds-noirs in Algeria. That makes Palestinians freedom fighters, they say. No state should be set up on the basis of ethnicity. Jews should not feel persecuted, they insist. Under the party’s rules, Jewish members cannot be punished for their beliefs, including Zionism. This new policy was born partly out of anger at the plight of the Palestinians. Israel’s government has treated the people of Gaza with merciless and unrelenting violence. Israeli settlers, sometimes motivated by hatred of Palestinians, are daily using force against them in the West Bank, often with the connivance of the army. However, Greens for Palestine, who prepared this policy, have got their history upside down. Far from being colonial, Zionism began as a liberation movement, like the Polish or Czech nationalism that emerged in the 19th century under the Austro-Hungarian empire. The pioneers did not look to Europe, as white Algerians did. Instead, Zionists claimed that Jews needed a homeland where they could be safe from pogroms—a belief later tragically borne out during the second world war and among Jews who fled Arab countries after 1948. The Greens are equally wrong about today. To blame all Israelis—all Zionists, indeed—for atrocities against Palestinians and to seek to punish them as a group is unjust. The Greens’ new policy only entrenches the divisions tearing the region apart. To say Israeli Jews could opt to live under a Palestinian government, possibly run by the murderers of Hamas, is to give them no choice at all. In Britain how can Green members of Parliament continue to serve their “racist” synagogue-going constituents? Will staffers look kindly on Jewish Greens accused of following a racist ideology? The pro-Palestine activists behind this motion are unlikely to tolerate either. Instead, the policy will
give succour to the thoughtless antisemitism that is already widespread on the far left and hard right. It is depressing that planet-loving Greens, who support things like eating lentils and planting trees, have indulged the hard left. Their leader, Zack Polanski (pictured), who is Jewish, did not take part in the vote, feebly pleading the need to campaign as the candidate in a by-election that was to be held on October 8th. He should grasp that his movement, which he remade as the more anti-capitalist alternative to Labour, has been taken over by zealots. These zealots express no real criticism of Putinists or Kim Jong Un or the Chinese Communist Party, let alone misgivings about Middle Eastern conflicts in Sudan, Syria or Yemen. But they have an unquenchable desire to denounce Zionists. Could this, possibly, have something to do with hating Jews? Instead of hand-wringing, the old Greens should seize back their party, or leave it. Worshipping in a synagogue is not tainted by racism. From this moment, voting Green in Britain is. ■ Correction (October 5th 2026): The original version of this story wrongly suggested that all white South Africans, including Boers, looked to London. This article was downloaded by zlibrary from https://www.economist.com/leaders/2026/10/04/britains-greens-have-voted-shamefully- to-say-zionism-is-racism
Brazil is a right-wing country now The Bolsonaro clan promises to align with Donald Trump, and to attack democratic institutions Oct 8th 2026 FOR MOST of the past quarter of a century Brazil was dominated by the Workers’ Party (PT). A left-wing alliance of trade-unionists, progressive Catholics and academics built a large welfare state and defined Latin America’s version of social democracy. That era is over. On October 4th the PT and its ageing leader, Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva, known as Lula, were trounced in the first round of Brazil’s general election by Flávio Bolsonaro and his Liberal Party (PL). Betting markets give Flávio a strong chance of winning the run-off on October 25th. It is an astounding result for the scion of a right-wing dynasty whose patriarch, Jair, an ex-president, is under house arrest for an attempted coup. Only last year Jair was barred from office until 2060. His son has
alleged connections to the criminal underworld. Despite that, Flávio narrowly fell short of winning outright. Even if Flávio unexpectedly fails, the election is a triumph for Brazil’s MAGA-adjacent right—the latest in a wave of successes for right-wing parties in Latin America. The PL now has the most powerful congressional caucus since Brazil’s constitution was enacted in 1988. It is also the largest party in the three biggest states, São Paulo, Rio de Janeiro and Minas Gerais, which together generate more than half of Brazilian GDP. The Bolsonaro clan is ecstatic. Jair’s ardently evangelical wife, two of his other sons and his brother all won seats in Congress. From February, when newly elected senators take their seats, the PL and allies will control the Senate and thus can rewrite laws. Expect them to boost business and to weaken protections for the environment. Some outsiders will warn against allowing more damage to the Amazon rainforest. Other outsiders, including America, will crave the opportunity to tap Brazil’s huge deposits of critical minerals, vital resources whose global supply is otherwise controlled largely by China. This congressional strength means the PL has a rare opportunity to fix Brazil’s ruinous public finances. Rewriting the laws which impose high and growing levels of government spending would curb borrowing, bring down interest rates and prompt investment—boosting growth. It gives the Bolsonaros scope to create a glittering economic future for Brazil. That would mean forgoing spending today, something for which the Bolsonaros have little appetite. The likelier outcome will be more polarised politics and pressure on Brazil’s vulnerable democratic institutions. The victors will exult in MAGA-style culture clashes. Two right-wing congressmen, Nikolas Ferreira and Lucas Pavanato, drew more votes than any candidates in Brazilian history; both are young social-media influencers who hate wokery as much as they love guns and God. The Bolsonaros will seek vengeance. Flávio’s big campaign promise was to free his father. Many candidates for the Senate vowed to bring down the Supreme Court justices (some caught up in corruption scandals) who
prosecuted Jair. “We don’t just want impeachment,” said Bia Kicis, a new PL senator, “we want removal, investigation and imprisonment.” A Senate majority is needed in order to impeach a Supreme Court justice. A stand-off between the two powerful institutions could trigger a constitutional crisis. Justices who believe themselves to be defending democracy will deploy their extensive powers in order to remain in office. An emboldened Congress will attack the court. Whoever is the president will play a decisive role, not least because in the coming years he will probably get to replace four of the Supreme Court’s 11 justices. However that fight ends, the outcome for Brazil is likely to be new grievances and deepening public cynicism. Brazilians have good reasons to reject the PT for its dead-end policies, its own corruption and the lack of fresh leadership. But they also have every reason to fear where that rejection now leads. ■ This article was downloaded by zlibrary from https://www.economist.com/leaders/2026/10/06/brazil-is-a-right-wing-country-now
Is back and shoulder surgery often worse than useless? Also this week, retro capitalism, mistaken identity, summer, AI-generated speeches Oct 8th 2026 Letters are welcome via email to letters@economist.comFind out more about how we process your letter Back and shoulder surgery is often worse than useless, you say (“The cost of cutting”, September 26th). You cast surgeons as the problem: “If your only tool is a scalpel, everything looks ripe for cutting.” My experience as an orthopaedic registrar is often the reverse. During our shoulder and spine clinics, much time is spent trying to talk patients out of operations. Many arrive convinced that a specific procedure is the only thing that will fix them. That belief may come from a friend, a referral letter, the internet or an