reminder of the contorted attempts to keep students safe, and how those efforts are letting them down. Looming over this and other cases of campus assault is Title IX, a 54-year- old civil-rights law. If it seems odd that a law barring sexual discrimination should be used to investigate rape, that is because its application is relatively recent. In 2011, after high-profile reports of sexual assaults at universities and tepid action by police, then-President Barack Obama used Title IX to offer students protections that it seemed criminal justice could not. The result has been a process that advances alongside any police investigation, with rules that are both looser and harsher than criminal ones. Title IX inquiries cannot compel witnesses to testify nor question them under oath; they also require merely a “preponderance” of evidence, rather than the obligation under criminal law that suspects be convicted only if their guilt is “beyond a reasonable doubt”. Universities have latitude to set their own punishments, as was evident in the Cornell case, where sanctions ranged from expulsion to writing essays. Title IX’s rules, already difficult for university administrators to implement well, have been made more so by the dramatic changes from one presidential administration to the next. In his first term Donald Trump
required universities to create their own quasi-judicial systems, with hearings, cross-examinations and more staff. Supporters say this added rigour; opponents claim the onerous process prompted accusers to drop allegations or never bring them (see chart). Federal oversight of universities’ inquiries also became more relaxed. Resolved investigations into sexual violence “fell off a cliff”, says Beth Gellman-Beer, a lawyer who spent years in the Education Department’s civil-rights office. Joe Biden sought to change the rules yet again, but Mr Trump reinstated his prior standard on September 28th and has cut the number of oversight staff. With so many shifting rules and inevitably imperfect administration, it is unclear if Title IX has had any impact on reducing sexual assaults. There is little national research. Cornell does poll its students, though. Last year 35% of female undergraduates reported experiencing sexual assault during their time at university, up from 23% a decade earlier. Criminologists say one of the best ways to deter crime is to increase the certainty that perpetrators are caught. Fifteen years on, Title IX seems to be falling short at that. ■ Stay on top of American politics with The US in brief, our daily newsletter with fast analysis of the most important political news, and Checks and Balance, a weekly note that examines the state of American democracy and the issues that matter to voters. This article was downloaded by zlibrary from https://www.economist.com/united-states/2026/10/08/how-not-to-make-campuses-safer
Big Tobacco’s lessons for Big Oil A lawsuit over climate change reaches the Supreme Court Oct 8th 2026 FOR DECADES after Americans discovered that cigarettes were killing them, tobacco companies won nearly every lawsuit that smokers brought. No one forced them to light up, the manufacturers said. Only after states uncovered evidence that firms knew of the risks posed by cigarettes—and hid them—did Big Tobacco capitulate, agreeing in 1998 to pay states more than $200bn over 25 years for the costs of treating smoking-related illness. A generation on, the Supreme Court is poised to decide if a similar reckoning is coming for oil companies. Like tobacco firms, oil companies sell products with dangerous consequences—and they too understood the risks before the general public did. But unlike tobacco, oil is broadly useful, and legal obstacles stand in the way of winning damages from oil firms, as arguments before the Supreme Court on October 5th demonstrated.
In 2018 Boulder, Colorado, sued Exxon Mobil and Suncor Energy on the basis that emissions from their products contributed to floods, extreme heat and wildfires. A report commissioned by the city put the cost of coping with just some of the impacts of climate change at up to $157m by 2050. The city alleges that the companies spent decades concealing the dangers of fossil fuels. A report commissioned in 1968 by the American Petroleum Institute (API), an industry group with links to Suncor’s predecessor company, warned that increased levels of carbon dioxide “may be the cause of serious worldwide environmental changes”. In the late 1970s scientists working for Exxon (a fellow member of the API) had found that burning fossil fuels could cause “dramatic environmental effects before the year 2050”. The effect of continued obfuscation, Boulder alleges, was to limit action on climate. The city says its suit is intended to make firms pay for the costs of their deception, not to stop the sale of fossil fuels. The companies see it differently: their lawyer, Kannon Shanmugam, claims the litigation tries to “resolve major political issues in court” and warns of allowing Boulder to sue “me on a nuisance claim for refilling my car”. Colorado’s state supreme court ruled that Boulder’s case could proceed, a decision that the companies appealed. Justice Samuel Alito, who owns shares in oil companies, recused himself from the case before the Supreme Court. Among the remaining justices, Boulder found some sympathy. During the oral argument, Justice Elena Kagan noted the case “appears to be based on the old 1990s tobacco suits”, with more recent opioid litigation following “the same model”. Big Oil lawsuits represented “chapter three”. Mr Shanmugam countered that the suit was an “unprecedented” use of state law to shape global conduct. Owing to the “ambient nature of air and water”, he said, the Supreme Court has held that “federal law governs interstate pollution claims”. Justice Brett Kavanaugh seemed to agree, declaring that “this kind of pollution is a federal-law matter unless Congress speaks otherwise.” Justice Amy Coney Barrett carved out more room for state efforts but agreed that dealing with pollution is an “enclave” of federal common law.
The added difficulty, for Boulder and other cities, is that it is hard to establish a direct causal link between the obfuscation of fossil fuels’ harms and climate change. Many governments, fully informed of the risks, still choose not to act, valuing the benefits of using fossil fuels over the damage of climate change. Smoking can be characterised as a problem of individual choice; states got around that by suing for the public costs. Climate change is a problem of collective action, one that politicians—even when they know the harms—choose not to solve. ■ Stay on top of American politics with The US in brief, our daily newsletter with fast analysis of the most important political news, and Checks and Balance, a weekly note that examines the state of American democracy and the issues that matter to voters. This article was downloaded by zlibrary from https://www.economist.com/united-states/2026/10/08/big-tobaccos-lessons-for-big-oil
Brazil falls into MAGA’s orbit The investment frenzy gripping Paraguay Latin America has caught motorcycle fever
Brazil falls into MAGA’s orbit The Bolsonaro clan and its allies have swept the country’s general election Oct 8th 2026 THE END of an era in Brazil may also mark the moment a dynasty truly established its hold. On October 4th Brazil’s ruling left-wing Workers’ Party (PT) and its ageing leader, Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva, were trounced in the first round of the general election. Flávio Bolsonaro, the scion of a right- wing patriarch, Jair (a former president under house arrest for attempting a coup), looks set to become the leader of the world’s fourth-largest democracy in a run-off on October 25th.
The defeat was enormous. Lula, as the incumbent is known, lost votes in more than 5,400 of the country’s 5,571 municipalities compared with the last election. Within states, the losses were greatest in the countryside (see chart). The Bolsonaros’ inaptly named Liberal Party (PL) almost doubled its seat tally in the Senate and cemented its status as the largest party in the lower house. Fernando Haddad, who is sometimes touted as Lula’s heir, was beaten by a margin of 26 points in his bid to oust São Paulo’s governor, all but burying his political future. This dominance puts Flávio in pole position to win the run-off. Since Brazil returned to democracy in 1985, no candidate who lost in the first round has gone on to win the second. Even if Flávio were to lose, the outcome is already a triumph for the Bolsonaro clan. Mr Bolsonaro’s zealous evangelical wife, his middle and youngest sons and his brother all won seats in the legislature. There are now nearly enough right-wing senators for the two-thirds majority needed to impeach Supreme Court justices who prosecuted his father.
The vote was less a reflection of enthusiasm for Flávio than a repudiation of the current government in an election marked by apathy. Over 33m of 158m eligible voters stayed away, the highest abstention rate since 1998. Polls published in the week of the ballot showed almost a third of voters did not know whom they would back. Outside a polling station in an upscale neighbourhood in Rio de Janeiro, a gloomy 24-year-old described the election as having “a funeral atmosphere”. “It’s about choosing the lesser evil,” shrugged his friend. The PT has been in power for 18 of the past 24 years and Brazilians are tiring of Lula, who at 80 still yearns for a fourth term. A former trade-union leader from Brazil’s poor hinterlands, he has failed to connect to younger, middle-class Brazilians, who tend to prefer gig work to union jobs and dream of being entrepreneurs. Flávio took 54% of votes among lower- middle class voters, against Lula’s 37%. Moreover, many voters do not trust the PT on the economy and are fed up over graft. Lula was jailed for corruption in 2018 though his convictions were overturned in 2021. A grubby corruption scandal involving Brazil’s biggest bank fraud also fuelled anti-establishment sentiment. Though Lula was not directly implicated, it has hurt him. A poll in mid-September found that voters were more likely to punish Lula than Flávio for the scandal.