government. Indian-made chips should roll off a Tata Electronics fab line early next year. Tata produces 46% of Apple’s Indian-made iPhones. It is responsible for turning around Air India, the privatised struggling flag- carrier, which commands about a quarter of domestic routes. Most of those champions are identified with a powerful owner-manager, or promoter, such as Gautam Adani of Adani Group or Mukesh Ambani of Reliance Industries. At Tata that figure was once Ratan Tata, Noel’s half- brother and for many years the chair of both the Trusts and the holding company. Ratan twice passed over Noel to run Tata Sons. He first chose Cyrus Mistry, whom he ousted in 2016 (and who died in 2022). He then picked Mr Chandrasekaran, who climbed the ranks of Tata Consultancy Services, an IT outsourcer. Almost as soon as Noel became chair of Tata Trusts after Ratan’s death in 2024, he clashed with Mr Chandrasekaran. The fight is heading to court. Both Tata Trusts and Tata Sons have recruited lawyers who are veterans of the battles that followed Mistry’s ousting. Noel Tata has declared the boardroom vote a “legal nullity”. Tata’s articles of association say that an agreement needs a majority of directors nominated by Tata Trusts: there are two, including Mr Tata. “Majority amongst two is two and not one,” the Trusts said. Tata Sons argues that a majority of the board, including the Trusts’ other representative and the vote of the director chairing the meeting, was sufficient. Others want a say. One is Shapoor Mistry, brother of the late Cyrus and brother-in-law of Mr Tata. Mr Mistry is the promoter at SP Group, an infrastructure firm, and Tata Sons’ largest minority shareholder, owning 18%. He is keen to sell his stake, in order to repay SP’s considerable debts. The Mistrys and the Tatas, both from the Parsi religious minority, have nearly a century of business entanglement. But perhaps the most powerful voice is the RBI’s. In 2021 the central bank required India’s biggest non-banking financial corporations to go public, after the collapse of an infrastructure lending company. Tata Sons has resisted, paying down all its debt and listing Tata Capital, its investment arm. On September 11th the RBI rejected Tata Sons’ latest attempt to fight the classification, leaving the firm with little choice.

The RBI has since tightened the net further. On September 22nd Business Standard, a newspaper, reported that the RBI was considering insisting on an accelerated listing to “remove any ambiguity” about its latest ruling. A listing would weaken Mr Tata’s power over the company, possibly removing the Trusts’ veto. He should not worry unduly: Messrs Adani and Ambani retain great power over their listed companies. But unlike Mr Tata, they have not alienated everyone else on their boards. A listing might not secure Mr Chandrasekaran’s third term, though. The court case will proceed under today’s articles of association: judges will decide what makes a majority. Some believe the government would be sad to see him go. Some believe it should be. “I think the world of Chandra,” said Jamie Dimon, the boss of JPMorgan Chase, America’s biggest bank, in Mumbai recently. “If I were the government, I would be concerned that this kind of conflict could deter foreign investment.” ■ This article was downloaded by zlibrary from https://www.economist.com/business/2026/09/24/tata-goes-to-war-with-itself

Business · Business | Red-hot autumn

German unions are fighting to defend the 35-hour week But that won’t stop the car industry’s decline Sep 24th 2026 The mood at Gate One of the Mercedes-Benz factory at Marienfelde, on the southern edge of Berlin, was combative. Several hundred people—workers in black factory uniforms and trade unionists in red T-shirts—blew whistles and waved placards demanding “Ola out!” (Ola Källenius is chief executive of Mercedes) and “The 35-hour workweek must stay”. Yasmin Fahimi, who chairs Germany’s trade-union confederation, told them 35 hours was “a red line”. Constantin Borchelt, head of the Berlin branch of IG Metall, the metalworkers’ union, produced a red vest, emblazoned with the number 35 and a smiling sun, worn by workers during the bitter but successful seven- week strike in 1984 that cut the week from 40 hours to 35.

IG Metall, the world’s biggest industrial trade union, with 2.2m members, had called for a “day of action” on September 21st for car-industry workers. Some 175,000 gathered at 280 events, at places including Wolfsburg (home to Volkswagen), Stuttgart (Mercedes and Porsche) and Ingolstadt (Audi). As well as aiming to defend the 35-hour week, the union wants a 5% pay rise and commitments that jobs and factories will be safe. Südwestmetall, an influential regional employers’ association, declared itself “aghast” at these demands. Talks about wages are due to begin on October 7th. Strikes could start as soon as November 1st. “This autumn will be uncomfortable,” predicts Marcus Berret of Roland Berger, a consulting firm. On the employers’ side, Mercedes is taking the lead on dismantling the 35- hour week, which is subject to separate talks. “If one carmaker nixes the 35 hours, the others will follow,” says Ferdinand Dudenhöffer, director of the Centre for Automotive Research, a think-tank. Mercedes is threatening to close two German factories unless workers agree to painful measures. It wants to extend the week to 40 hours without extra pay and to reconsider perks such as bonus pay for Christmas and holidays, in a “productivity offensive”. “It simply does not make business sense to produce cars in Germany any more,” says Oliver Fenzl, a company spokesman. Labour costs have long been higher in Germany than elsewhere in Europe (let alone China), but in the past they were offset by cheap energy, freer trade and China’s voracious demand for German cars, especially premium models with fat margins. But today energy prices are sky-high, trade is less open and the Chinese are making their own cars (including premium ones) in abundance. Mercedes’s sales in China have dropped by 27% and profits by 50% in the past three years; domestic carmakers’ market share has doubled to 70% in the past five. Failure to match Chinese competition largely explains why earlier this month Volkswagen said it would cut 50,000 jobs and close four factories in Germany in the next few years. Meanwhile the wage gap with the rest of Europe has widened. Hourly pay at Mercedes’s factory in Kecskemet in Hungary is around €15.60 ($17.80); Germans are on €49.50. This year the firm doubled Kecskemet’s capacity to 400,000 cars a year. It is now bigger than any of its German plants.

Union leaders call management’s cost-cutting proposals a “horror catalogue”. Far from accepting a 35-hour week, they suggest cutting it to 30, which they say could preserve jobs and capacity (if at a lower weekly wage). The two sides will probably muddle through for now—compromise is the norm—but they are unlikely to stop the shrinkage of what was once the crown jewel of German industry. In 2018 carmakers employed around 830,000, says Mr Dudenhöffer. Now the figure is 700,000 and he forecasts it will be 500,000 by around 2030. A few years ago this would have been dismissed as a horror scenario. Now a selection from the horror catalogue may be the best option. ■ This article was downloaded by zlibrary from https://www.economist.com/business/2026/09/24/german-unions-are-fighting-to-defend- the-35-hour-week

Business · Business | Bartleby

The greatest advance in consulting since the quadrant An exclusive extract from a new book Sep 24th 2026 “Iremember it as though it were yesterday.” Wendy Clanger smiles as she recalls the events of April 1st 2017. Clanger, whose petite frame hides an iron will, had been a consultant for decades, and thought she had seen everything. “Radar charts, quadrant matrices, waterfalls: I’d used them all. I thought the geometry of consulting was complete. But I hadn’t banked on Harbour.” Harbour Brandish was 23, bespectacled, just out of college. When he was assigned to Clanger’s team, she assumed he was just another bright trainee, one of hundreds she had seen come and go. His first engagement was for a fast-moving consumer-goods firm called MidPoint, and he was in the room when Clanger presented some competitor analysis.

Vic von Ursen, a bear of a man whose gruff manner disguises a heart of gold, takes up the story. “We all knew that the client lagged Flummox, its main rival. But when Wendy laid it out, the gap was so much bigger than we had realised.” In slide after slide, Clanger used a classic quadrant to map the performance of MidPoint and its peers in different product categories. “It was standard stuff,” says von Ursen, who had spent 20 years in the industry by then. “You want to be in the top right-hand box. You always want to be in the top right-hand box.” But something bothered him. Flummox was doing so much better than anyone else that it was always in the very top corner of the quadrant. Even then, “we were having to break the scale on some axes to fit it into the chart. It was as if the quadrant wasn’t able to cope.” Von Ursen said as much to the team. Everyone agreed but the quadrant was all they knew. They had been trained on it since the start of their careers. None of them could think outside the four boxes. No one except Harbour Brandish. “It just seemed obvious to me. I couldn’t work out why no one else was saying it.” So he stuck up his hand. “I saw Harbour wanted to speak,” says Clanger. “I didn’t know that the next three words would change the industry.” “Add another box.” “I thought I must have misheard him,” says Clanger. “So I asked him to repeat it.” “Add another box.” The room went quiet and then people started to laugh. Vic von Ursen was among them. “It was the stupidest thing I had ever heard. I regret that laugh more than anything I have ever done.” Clanger didn’t laugh. A sixth sense told her that Brandish was onto something. So she asked him what he meant.