His henchmen are no subtler. Facebook’s comically horrid PR man says that the social network is better than any nation. “We’re post-government around here,” he sneers, when threatened with regulation. The now-familiar notion that the company puts profit before the greater good is conveyed with a megaphone. “If engagement keeps falling…it’ll be a bad earnings report!” squeals one executive, as the company debates whether to tone down its wickedness. The second difficulty for the movie is that its subject matter is more nuanced than Mr Sorkin would like. The film’s central question—should Facebook suppress bad content?—is not so simple. The script implies that Facebook should take down lies. But should the flawed Mr Zuckerberg therefore be elevated to a global arbiter of truth? Some dialogue is unintentionally persuasive to the contrary. “The voters aren’t children,” argues Mr Zuckerberg in one scene. “Facebook isn’t the ref…We’re the public square.” Quite. Mr Sorkin’s earnestness was perfectly tempered by Mr Fincher’s cynicism in “The Social Network”. It was a movie with no real heroes, between the perfidious Mr Zuckerberg and those he trampled, including a flash Sean Parker (an early supporter) and the absurd Winklevoss twins (who say Mr Zuckerberg stole their idea). The “Reckoning”, by contrast, is divided neatly into goodies (diligent journalist, brave whistleblower) and baddies (scheming Zuckerberg, robotic cronies). The outcome is an unsatisfying caricature. Film and TV schedules have lately been clogged with dramatisations of Silicon Valley. The most successful ones have tended to be those based on true stories, including what happened at Uber (“Super Pumped”), WeWork (“WeCrashed”) and Theranos (“The Dropout”). But now those corporate dramas are well-known—and helped make up people’s minds about the Valley’s recklessness. Yet more takes are on the way. On October 8th Paramount+ will launch “Cupertino”, a series about a fictional law firm fighting big tech. A new documentary about Theranos’s Elizabeth Holmes will come out this month, too. In December “Artificial”, starring Andrew Garfield as Sam Altman, will be the first movie to tell the story of OpenAI. “The Social Network” remains
the model for how to do it well. Alas, its follow-up offers a reminder of what a hard act it is to follow. ■ This article was downloaded by zlibrary from https://www.economist.com/culture/2026/10/07/the-social-reckoning-is-a-fatally- earnest-sequel-to-a-classic
Malcolm Gladwell and Harel Shapira are up in arms about guns But can you be convinced of their views, if you are not already on their side? Oct 8th 2026 FEW THINGS about Americans baffle foreigners more than their attachment to guns. Thirty years ago mass shootings in Australia and Scotland prompted both countries to tighten their gun laws; today, legally owning a handgun in Britain is almost impossible and getting one in Australia requires licensing, registration and a background check. In America, meanwhile, 40% of people live in a household with a gun, and each year more than 1m Americans become first-time gun owners. What explains this form of American exceptionalism? Two new books try to answer that question in very different ways.
Malcolm Gladwell, a prolific Canadian journalist who lives in America, has written a book that follows his familiar formula: ten short chapters crammed with anecdotes wrapped around nuggets of wisdom, like social-science fortune cookies. “The American Way of Killing” emerged from a series on his popular podcast, “Revisionist History”; annoyingly, it reads like it, with whole chunks of raw transcript slapped down on the page. But, as with most of Mr Gladwell’s books, readers will come away thinking differently about the world. For instance, one of the few gun-control measures most Americans support is a ban on assault weapons. Mr Gladwell argues it would do little; most gun deaths involve handguns, which are readily available. Many on the American left would be happy to shrink police forces; Mr Gladwell notes that European cities tend to have larger police forces than similarly sized American ones and argues that keeps them safe, because their presence helps prevent crimes. Mr Gladwell’s usually fluid writing has a shrill, rebarbative edge. He accuses Americans of “moral recklessness”, misdiagnosing “the nature of the violence that plagues their streets” and having a “fundamentally dishonest way” of discussing guns. “Not only do Americans get things wrong, but they seem uninterested in ever getting things right,” he huffs. Those who share his views on guns may enjoy his scolding, but his tone will turn some off. Harel Shapira, by contrast, does far more showing than telling. A sociologist at the University of Texas, Mr Shapira spent years taking firearms-training classes in Texas to better understand why and how guns appeal to ordinary Americans. The instructors are dedicated professionals, mostly conservative but not nutters “running tactical drills deep in the woods in preparation for a battle with the deep state”. Both students and instructors sincerely believe that owning and knowing how to use guns will help keep them safer. Mr Shapira and his fellow students do not just learn to load, aim and clean their weapons. They are also taught “the ‘warrior mindset’" or “the state of mind that we ‘good guys with guns’ were meant to embrace”. The school’s founder says that there are three types of people: sheep (passive), wolves (predatory) and the type he wants them to be: sheepdogs, who protect the
flock. The police are a “reactive force” who often arrive too late; a sheepdog has to always be prepared for danger. The school’s founder encourages them to carry their guns loaded. “There are bad guys everywhere,” he warns. Many of Mr Shapira’s fellow students fear petrol stations, where they feel vulnerable when they get out of their cars to refuel. For his instructors, Mr Shapira writes, “a diverse and vibrant public sphere does not hold the promise of a fulfilling life. It holds only the potential for a violent death.” The consequences of a mindset that encourages an armed response to ubiquitous danger quickly becomes clear. One of his instructors shot and killed a young black man who broke into his home. It turned out he was a mentally disabled resident of a nearby group home who had escaped and ran down the street, banging on front doors. When the young man, dishevelled and probably “cold, frightened, disoriented”, did not heed the instructor’s orders to leave, he shot him five times. Was the instructor a “good guy with a gun”? Some thought so: he faced no charges. Mr Shapira is not so sure. But what makes his book so exceptional is that his personal doubts did not stop him from listening to his instructor’s story with empathy, curiosity and understanding—all of which he extends to his subjects. In that sense, these two books are not just about guns; they present two ways of engaging in culture-war arguments. Both authors dislike guns and presumably wrote their books to persuade others of their beliefs. Mr Gladwell tries to scold his opponents into submission, which seldom works. Mr Shapira, however, listens and shows his readers a world full of complex people rather than caricatures. Whether any author can change minds on this issue is a bleaker question. A majority of American adults has been threatened with a gun, seen someone shot or had a family member killed by a gun, according to KFF, a think-tank. Yet in recent years American gun laws have become only laxer, with states embracing “permitless carry” of firearms. America’s gun-violence problem will last until voters follow Australians and Britons—and decide they have had enough. ■
This article was downloaded by zlibrary from https://www.economist.com/culture/2026/10/08/malcolm-gladwell-and-harel-shapira- are-up-in-arms-about-guns
Fancy a tour through the Middle East? A new history of the region takes you across thousands of miles and more than a century Oct 8th 2026 By some accounts it was the most expensive party in history. To commemorate the 2,500th anniversary of the founding of the Persian empire, Muhammad Reza Pahlavi, the last shah of Iran, invited kings, queens, emperors and presidents to celebrate in a lavish encampment amid the ancient ruins of Persepolis. Guests sipped champagne from Moët & Chandon and wine from Château Lafite Rothschild. They feasted on food from Maxim’s of Paris and gawked at 50,000 imported songbirds. (The creatures all died in the heat.) Iranians were outraged by the excess. “We can hardly offer them bread and radishes,” came the shah’s tone-deaf retort. For Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini, the architect and father of Iran’s revolution, the party was the
“devil’s festival”. It marked the beginning of the end of the shah’s rule. Seven years later, the shah fled from the country. Those close to him were executed. Even his horse was publicly tortured and shot. The party was over. In a previous book, Simon Sebag Montefiore, a British historian, took on the history of the world. “The Cauldron”, his latest work, is somehow even more ambitious: it tackles the history of the Middle East since 1900. You might wonder whether there is much new to be said on the subject. Rich histories of the Arabs abound. The conflict between the Israelis and Palestinians has generated, by Mr Montefiore’s own admission, “a veritable industry” of analysis. Countless tomes pick through the diplomacy, wars and revolutions that have shaped the region. Mr Montefiore’s contribution distinguishes itself in a number of ways. He takes on the entire middle, including Turkey, Iran, Israel and the Arab countries: this is a surprisingly rare approach. More than that, he brings the reader to the present day, analysing events that continue to unfold. He aims to “lighten the heavy matters of religion, geopolitics and ideology” by telling this history through “human stories, often those of rulers”. And Mr Montefiore aspires to restore “some balance” to the way those in the West look at the Middle East. None is an easy task. Yet the sheer scope of “The Cauldron” is breathtaking. He whizzes around the region, from Mustafa Kemal Ataturk battling Allied troops in 1915 to Riyadh, as it was seized by Abdulaziz bin Abdul Rahman al-Saud to establish the kingdom of Saudi Arabia in 1932. Then the book marches onwards, through the founding of Israel, the Iranian revolution, the horror of Sudan’s civil war and the bloodshed of the past three years. The breadth of the book inevitably means depth is sacrificed. The Armenian genocide of 1915-16 is dealt with in less than a page. But Mr Montefiore also manages to include a rich array of details that bring the grand sweep to life (for example the fact that, after America, Iran was the second country to recognise the new state of Israel; or the comment by Gamal Abdel Nasser of Egypt to Leonid Brezhnev that if he were Israel’s leader: “I’d never give up the Occupied Territories.”)