Britain faces fiscal consolidation, whether via tax rises or spending cuts. A generation ago, pensioners were among the poorest in society. When Margaret Thatcher left office in 1990, 40% were in poverty. Now, pensioner households often have higher incomes than working-age ones. “From each according to his ability; to each according to his age” cannot survive against this backdrop. Those of all ages must share the pain. When age trumps class, demography determines election results. Big generations, such as the boomers, bullied governments at the ballot box. When they retired, Britain became a dictatorship of the pensionariat. Then, in 2020, millennials became the biggest cohort. And so the general election of 2024 was the first one someone born in the 1950s would have lost if they had voted with the bulk of their cohort. Actuarial tables can be as useful as any poll. Systems die when people no longer truly believe in them. Late-stage pensioner communism is riddled with hypocrisy. After Mr Burnham’s speech, Conservative politicians who privately slate the triple lock ardently defended it. But like Soviet functionaries going home to listen to The Beatles on an illicit Sony Walkman, they know that the system is doomed. Blind faith can be just as deadly. Outrageous demands are made of an already failing regime. Why shouldn’t the state pension be the same as the minimum wage, asks Prem Sikka, a Labour peer? That it would leave the pension budget equivalent to the state’s combined spending on education, defence, transport, the police, the courts, prisons and debt interest is no matter. Nothing is too good for the pensioners! “It had never even occurred to me that in the Soviet Union anything could ever change. Let alone that it could disappear,” said Andrei Makarevich, a Russian singer. “There was a complete impression that everything was for ever.” What happens when for ever comes to an end? When a hegemonic idea crumbles, the vacuum can be filled only by others. Mr Burnham has proposed plenty. Rejoining the EU was once a mad dream. It could happen in a decade, if the prime minister is to be taken at his word. Ditto the dull- but-profound issue of voting reform. This is not only an opportunity for liberals. Taboos about racism could melt just as quickly. “Who? Whom?” could have a dark answer.
British politics feels stuck in an eternal present, with little true recollection of what the country once was and no idea of what it could be. Its norms are inevitable and impossible to shift, until they do. The answer to “Who? Whom?” can never change, even though it always does eventually. Pensioner communism is coming to an end. Everything is for ever, until it is no more. ■ This article was downloaded by zlibrary from https://www.economist.com/britain/2026/10/08/the-coming-fall-of-pensioner-communism
Nagging people to eat healthily does not work Taxes, planning rules, limits on ads—anything to curb junk food Oct 8th 2026 Sunday afternoons in Simón Bolívar park are an orgy of calories. Many stalls in this green corner of Colombia’s capital, Bogotá, sell obleas: sandwiches of wafers stuffed with layers of fattening fillings, including syrups, jams, caramel and cheese. An acid green “bubble-gum” sauce is among the enticing options. “Life’s too short not to eat the food that you love”, reads a sign above one of the stalls. So Colombians evidently believe. A quarter of them are obese, according to the UN’s World Health Organisation, a share that has risen fivefold since 1980. Diabetes, high blood pressure and kidney disease—all chronic conditions associated with obesity—are rife. The health-care system, already severely underfunded and then stretched almost to breaking point by covid- 19, has struggled to cope.
In 2022 the previous government decided radical action was needed. It required all processed food with high levels of sugar, salt or the unhealthiest forms of fat to be labelled as such, with big black warning signs. More important, it imposed a 10% tax on such products, which rose to 15% in 2024 and 20% last year. Colombia is not the only place that is meddling in the food business to counter obesity. On September 29th Gavin Newsom, the governor of California, who is likely to run for president in 2028, signed a bill requiring grocery chains to place healthy foods in “high-traffic areas” within stores. A law came into effect in Scotland on October 1st barring big businesses from displaying unhealthy foods prominently in shops and from offering promotions that encourage bulk purchases of them, such as buy-one-get-one- free deals. In India on October 6th a public consultation ended on a proposal to prohibit sales of junk food to children within 50 metres of a school. The state of Maharashtra already has such a law, barring sales of junk food to anyone near a school. Heavy-handed policies like these used to be a rarity. Between 1992 and 2020 Britain adopted no fewer than 14 official government plans to curb rising obesity (not counting the initiatives of devolved governments in Northern Ireland, Scotland and Wales). Those plans involved 689 individual policies. The majority aimed to make consumers more aware of the health risks of junk food and to provide better access to healthy alternatives, especially in schools. None banned any forms of junk food, only 3% restricted access to it and only two policies (or 0.3% of the total) created any financial disincentive to consume it, such as higher taxes.
This cajoling approach has failed. England’s obesity rate has doubled since the early 1990s. About a fifth of 11-year-olds are now obese. In both rich countries and poorer ones, obesity rates have been rising steadily (see chart). In America 72% of adults are obese or overweight. In Mexico 74% are. All this costs the countries in the OECD, a club mostly of rich countries, an average of 3% of GDP a year in health-care spending and lost productivity. Although GLP-1 drugs, the weight-loss treatments that have become commonplace in the rich world in recent years, hold out the hope of dramatically reducing obesity, they are pricey, especially considering patients must remain on them indefinitely. Poorer countries, in particular, will struggle to provide them to a big proportion of the population. Politicians are instead turning to a bewildering array of policies intended not to persuade people to change their habits, but rather to alter the “food environment” around them. Many of the new rules concern labels. About ten years ago health officials in Britain, France and elsewhere created simple symbols in traffic-light colours to rank foods from best to worst, either for ingredients of concern (such as fat, sugar and salt) or overall, based on a formula that takes into account healthy ingredients, too. Many countries have since adopted such easily digestible scoring systems—but most remain voluntary.
That is changing fast. A bill to make France’s labels mandatory has been introduced in parliament. Singapore will soon oblige manufacturers to label foods that score poorly under its system. The most sweeping rules, however, involve warning labels like Colombia’s, akin to the frightening messages many countries require on cigarette packets. Since 2016, for instance, Chile has obliged manufacturers to place as many as four black, stop-sign-shaped alerts on the front of unhealthy products, depending on how many ingredients exceed the regulatory threshold. Canada adopted similar rules earlier this year. Such rules have an impact, both by deterring buyers and by prompting chastened manufacturers to alter recipes to avoid being branded unhealthy. A recent analysis of Mexico’s labelling law, which came into effect in 2020, concluded that it had led to a 15% drop in calories sold, a 25% drop in added sugar and 12% drop in saturated fats, even as overall sales volumes remained stable. About 90% of the reduction in calories was the result of products being reformulated, rather than of people changing which products they bought. Restrictions on marketing unhealthy foods are also proliferating. About a dozen countries ban television ads for junk food when children are likely to be watching or bar ads and packaging from appealing to children using cartoon characters and the like. In January Britain went a step further, banning ads for unhealthy foods online and on social media, following a similar move by Portugal in 2019. Local governments can be especially zealous. In 2022 New York banned junk-food ads on all city property, as have several places in Australia and Britain. Amsterdam and London ban them on public transport. Then there are restrictions on where unhealthy foods can be sold. Britain’s planning law was amended in 2024 to allow local authorities to ban new fast-food joints within walking distance of a secondary school—although so many such outlets already exist that the new rules may have little effect. Maharashtra’s law is much more restrictive, but enforcement is patchy. The difficulty of enforcement is one of the many drawbacks of complex rules around junk food. They can place heavy burdens on businesses, which also often find creative ways around them. Since 2022, for example, Britain