£100,000 per person per year. Any new rules could be made retroactive, forcing Reform to return most of the dosh. The worriers make three intertwined arguments. They claim that Reform habitually bends and even breaks the rules; that the cash gives the party an unfair advantage; and that big money harms politics. Only one of these claims holds water. The whiff of impropriety around Reform is real. In early September the party suspended two senior figures after they were filmed apparently encouraging a would-be donor to break the rules on giving. Mr Farage was filmed slurping down oysters while others discussed the rule-breaking. (He insists he was not listening properly, which is hardly much of a defence.) Parliament and the police are investigating other donations. Rules must be followed, including those on donations from abroad. But people who care about the health of British politics should not try to restrict the flow of legal money into it. Britain suffers not from an excess of political donations, but from a severe lack of them. One reason not to block money is that, after a certain point, cash cannot simply buy victory in elections. And even if it could, restrictions on campaign spending in Britain are a leveller. In the case of Reform, the windfall could grow poisonous as factions already at war within the party struggle for a share of the spoils. The other reason is that British politics needs money. Last year the Donkey Sanctuary, a charity in Devon that cares for down-on-their-luck equines, received more than every major political party combined. So did the Royal Opera House. Or compare Britain with America. Reform’s £72m windfall is worth less than the money spent on this year’s Republican Senate primary election in Texas. Impoverished British parties are barely able to prepare for power. The victor of a general election wins control of more than £1.3trn in public spending; those vying for this prize do so on a shoestring. Most shadow ministers rely on teams of two or three staffers to put together a programme for government. Reform boasts that it will use its new infusion of cash to double

the number of policy researchers it has—to a grand total of 20. If so, it would be a start. Although British voters prefer the asses in Devon to the asses in Westminster, their blanket cynicism about politics is unwarranted. Britons seem to assume that any donation must be corrupt, because why else would the donor hand over their cash? But if giving to political parties is stigmatised as spivvy, only spivs will give. Politics would benefit from a wider pool of public-spirited donors to fund the lawyers and wonks who prepare parties for office. Restricting donations would make this problem worse. And doing so retroactively would discredit the rule of law. When Parliament has previously made past actions unlawful, it was to pursue elderly Nazis and Yugoslav war criminals. Turning the election rulebook into a tool for the establishment to keep insurgents out really would be a gift to Mr Farage. If you are an opponent of Reform, you should shun the donkeys this year and pick the party you want to win. Instead of reaching for the statute book, with one hand hold your nose and with the other reach for your chequebook. ■ This article was downloaded by zlibrary from https://www.economist.com/leaders/2026/09/16/there-is-too-little-money-in-british- politics-not-too-much

Letters · Letters | A selection of correspondence

How do you improve your gut microbiome? Also this week, Swedish wine, Norway’s new king, Britain’s hot summers, Charles de Gaulle and the Bayeux tapestry Sep 17th 2026 Letters are welcome via email to letters@economist.comFind out more about how we process your letter Your Well Informed column on the gut microbiome (August 15th) was right about the thing that matters most. There is no single ideal microbiome, and a varied, plant-heavy, partly fermented diet remains the most reliable way to improve your gut microbiome. However, you also claim that the idea that particular microbes matter to health has “scant published scientific basis”. A large-scale analysis of over 34,000 individuals across Britain and America was published in Nature earlier this year, pinpointing specific microbial species that consistently correlate with positive and negative health indicators internationally.

Although my co-authors and I clearly stated that these findings reflect association rather than causation—highlighting the necessity for further interventional trials—the evidence is far from scant, and the raw dataset remains publicly available. Indeed, the vital role of gut health has recently been formally acknowledged in the US Department of Agriculture’s 2026 guidelines. Continued pioneering research in this field is undoubtedly essential. Moreover, the National Institute of Standards and Technology study you cited identifies seven companies and never names them. It also found that reproducibility varied enormously between firms. Readers meeting it directly after a paragraph about ZOE, a firm I helped found, may infer something the paper does not say. This field deserves scepticism; a great deal of what is sold in it is indefensible. It also deserves to be judged on what has actually been published. Professor Tim SpectorCo-founderZOELondon Your article on growing wine in Sweden mentioned that once a winery wins approval, its “distribution is in effect handled by the government” (“Vin- dinavia”, August 22nd). This is good news, you think, as a mechanism for quality control. Systembolaget is a state monopoly on the sale of wine and spirits to the public in Sweden. A monopoly retailer decides which producers reach the public. That is the antithesis of a liberal market, and no amount of good wine at the other end of it changes what it is. Growers must satisfy one buyer (the state) or reach no consumer at all. The state sets the terms, and the terms reward what a bureaucracy can measure. That means volume and consistency. A young industry needs the freedom to fail at both. After years of lobbying, Swedish winemakers may now sell a bottle at their own gate, on conditions strict enough to leave the retail monopoly intact. The justification for that monopoly has shifted as well. Systembolaget was built to protect public health by trying to limit how much people drank. It is now credited with building an industry, by a state that spent decades urging people to drink more wine. No industry should have to thank the state for

permission to reach consumers. GRAHAM BUTLERFull professor of lawLinnaeus UniversityVäxjö, Sweden Regarding Norway’s monarchy (“Long to reign over Oslo”, September 5th), in 1905 Norwegians were asked whether Prince Carl, the future Haakon VII, should be invited to become our king. The endorsement of monarchy was implicit. The invitation was personal. A fine distinction, perhaps, but his great-grandson, Haakon VIII, might have found considerable promise in the precedent. Given his personal popularity, the new king would have had little to fear from asking Norwegians to confirm him as their sovereign. Such an endorsement would have given him a mandate of his own, helped turn the page on his family’s scandals and offered even republicans a reason to accept his reign. And the question of the monarchy’s future might have been laid to rest for a generation. It might also have sown the seeds of a new constitutional practice: hereditary succession subject to popular consent. The family would provide the candidate; the electorate would issue the invitation. Norway could retain the continuity and stability of monarchy while giving each sovereign a democratic warrant to serve. Affection for Haakon’s late father, King Harald, may smooth his accession. It cannot confer consent in perpetuity. Alas, it may now fall to his daughter to seek that consent, provided there is still a throne to inherit by then. Torbjorn Graff HugoOslo

Tim Palmer’s By Invitation column (September 5th) asked what Britain should do before next summer to tackle extremely hot weather. A memoir by Evelyn Cox on “The Great Drought of 1976”, which I found by chance in a second-hand shop, is illuminating. The Met Office judged that drought and the record wet winter implied no lasting change. The Climatic Research Unit at East Anglia at the time was telling planners to expect drier summers. But Britain gambled on getting through the summer without drastic steps, and was rescued by the winter rain. Ms Cox, carting water by lorry after her farm pond dried out, wrote that the lesson of 1976 is that water is not an easy substance to move. The quantities are so large that a national grid would be astronomically expensive, and other methods—tanker ships, containers towed behind barges, reversing rivers—raised as many problems as they solved. Her own conclusion was simpler. Act early, and impose savings before the reservoirs get too low, “because a gamble may not pay off a second time”. BARBARA CLANCYDublin Your article on relations between Britain and France mentioned the new film about Charles de Gaulle, “La Bataille de Gaulle” (“From Paris with love”, September 5th). The film depicts a crucial event: the Battle of Bir Hakeim in 1942. The encounter in north Africa proved to Winston Churchill the