world. Dr Diamond makes a convincing case that no other leader could have done what he did. You might conclude from this and other examples that good presidents seek to represent the whole country, rather than just their tribe; that they learn from the best minds and that they avoid picking fights with neighbours. Yet plenty of people win power without these qualities. Many voters like their leaders tribal, belligerent and scornful of expertise; hence the recent surge of populist nationalism. In the end, trying to pin down what makes a good leader is hard because so many useful qualities are useful only in the appropriate dose. Tenacity is great, but not when it hardens into stubbornness. Courage, but not recklessness; compassion, but not being a soft touch; vision, but not loopiness. A point Dr Diamond hints at but does not explore is that the people who select leaders, in politics, business and other spheres, have a duty to choose soberly; that they should have realistic expectations of what a leader can accomplish and reject the conmen who promise instant golden ages. It is a duty often neglected. ■ This article was downloaded by zlibrary from https://www.economist.com/culture/2026/09/17/the-right-way-to-learn-from-genghis- khan

Culture · Culture | Crowd control

The rise of the phone-free concert A growing band of musicians wants fans to experience gigs the old- fashioned way Sep 17th 2026 “This machine is killing me,” croons Phoebe Bridgers in “Lost Boys”, her new song. She does not say whether she has a particular device in mind (or whether, like Rage Against the Machine, she is using the term as a metaphor for the establishment). But, given that her song is about self-destruction and stunted maturity, she may well be referring to a smartphone. Elsewhere, however, Ms Bridgers has been loud and clear about her feelings towards the gadgets: she has banned phones during her world tour, which kicked off on September 14th. To gain entry, ticket-holders will have to seal their devices inside pouches that are then magnetically locked for the duration of the gig. That means no filming or taking photos, as fans annoyingly do at other performances. According to Samsung, a phonemaker,

each concert-goer in Britain records on average 12 and a half minutes of video per show. She is not alone in enforcing such rules. Alicia Keys, Childish Gambino and Jack White have all banned smartphones at their gigs. Sir Paul McCartney barred them at two concerts he played in Los Angeles earlier this year. Bob Dylan’s upcoming tour will be phone-free. For some musicians, nostalgia plays a part in their decision. Sir Paul described his LA concerts as “really special”: “It was like an old gig, like how everyone used to play.” But the anti-tech trend is not just a yearning for simpler times. Rather, the hope is that fans will get more out of the live- music experience. The idea is that it is all the more special for being ephemeral. Getting your hands on a ticket means getting to enjoy the company of your favourite musician and fellow enthusiasts without a screen in the way. Artists aver that concerts should be appreciated in the moment, not videoed for social media. At Harry Styles’s recent gig in Manchester, guests had to put their phones away, but they were given disposable cameras along with a note: “Thank you for really being here with me. Dance with all your friends.” The effect is scarcity—the only way to experience the show is to be there in person—and that may only heighten fans’ fear of missing out. Musicians have argued that the exclusivity is part of the point. Mr Dylan has said that the fact his performances will be “device-free” will “make the occasion even more unique”. Music is meant to connect the performer and the listener. Artists have said that they hate looking out at a sea of iPhones rather than smiling faces. Ghost, a Swedish metal group, banned phones on its tour in 2025; their front man cited the “ever-growing distance I felt between the crowd and the band”. Kaytranada, a Canadian DJ, put it more bluntly: “It looks mad awkward from where I stand.” ■ This article was downloaded by zlibrary from https://www.economist.com/culture/2026/09/14/the-rise-of-the-phone-free-concert

Culture · Culture | Staying grounded

The world’s most essential habitat does not get its proper due A new book, “The World Beneath Our Feet”, digs into the significance of soil Sep 17th 2026 Just as there are charismatic species, there are charismatic habitats. Indeed, the two often overlap. Rainforests have beautiful birds and butterflies. African savannahs are filled with elephants and lions. Then there are the uncharismatic habitats with uncharismatic species. Mites, centipedes and millipedes, anyone? Slime moulds and woodlice? And nematodes, nematodes, nematodes. These unloved critters, along with countless earthworms, are denizens of what is probably the least charismatic habitat of all: soil.

And yet the soil and its inhabitants are the most important ecosystems of the lot, argues Frank Ashwood, an ecologist. Without them, rainforests and savannahs would not exist—for these more telegenic biomes are, quite literally, rooted in the soil. So is agriculture, which has fed humanity since Homo sapiens worked out how to farm. If you want biodiversity, soil provides it. According to Dr Ashwood, a teaspoon of healthy topsoil can hold up to 6bn micro-organisms; a square metre of temperate woodland or grassland soil contains some 300 earthworms, 50,000 springtails, 100,000 mites and 5m nematodes. Moreover, for those who fret about global warming, soil is a great way to keep carbon out of the atmosphere. The carbon stored in a hectare of boreal- forest soil, for example, weighs more than a jumbo jet. Ignore the soil, then, at your peril. Partly, ignorance is a result of soil being, quite literally, dirt. Handle it, and it gets everywhere. Get it in a cut, and you may be advised to seek a tetanus shot and antibiotics. But there is also the matter of visibility. Air and water are transparent. Soil is not. The creatures that live in it may lead lives as exciting as those of forest-dwellers, but they are hidden from human sight. Dig them up, though, and the result is awesome. A species of mites, for example, has evolved to make antifreeze proteins so they can live in the soils of sub-Antarctic islands. Pseudoscorpions have learned to hitch-hike to new homes by grasping onto flying insects such as beetles. Slime moulds form feeding networks so efficient that planners can use them to model public- transport networks. Woodlice include a species which couples up (in a way almost unheard-of in invertebrates), so that one partner can defend the burrow containing their young while the other forages. And nematodes, reckoned to make up 80% of individual living animals, have been brought back to life by scientists from ancient samples of frozen Siberian tundra. Human beings, in Dr Ashwood’s telling, are not good soil mates. Modern machine-based farming not only leads to soil erosion; it also damages what soil remains by compacting together the particles, thus preventing creatures from traversing them. The result is a huge loss of species diversity.

In some parts of the world, though, there is a backlash. “No-till” and regenerative agriculture aim both to conserve existing soil biodiversity and increase it. Done well, this approach can be more profitable than conventional modern methods. If Sir David Attenborough is looking for a swansong, then, he could do worse than release his camera crews on the world’s soils. The travel budget would probably be as high as that demanded by a more conventional wildlife documentary, for Dr Ashwood draws his examples from Africa, the Amazon, Australia, New Zealand, Ukraine and even the highlands of Scotland, as well as North America and his native England. Not so much “Life on Earth”, then, as “Life in Earth”. ■ This article was downloaded by zlibrary from https://www.economist.com/culture/2026/09/17/the-worlds-most-essential-habitat- does-not-get-its-proper-due

Culture | “The Last Man”, still standing Is Francis Fukuyama the most misunderstood public intellectual? “The End of History” was not the end of him. The oft-cited, and criticised, professor is back with a new memoir Sep 17th 2026 WHEN FRANCIS Fukuyama, then a 40-year-old political scientist, published “The End of History and the Last Man” in 1992, the book was met with acclaim. With the collapse of the Soviet Union and end of the cold war, the world had reached “the end point of mankind’s ideological evolution” with “the universalisation of Western liberal democracy as the final form of human government”, he argued. There would be no more big causes for which to struggle. After Donald Trump spearheaded a global wave of populist, illiberal nationalism a quarter-century later, Mr Fukuyama’s book became an emblem of liberal hubris. How could anyone have been so foolish as to suggest