More than 70% of Britons believe knife attacks are rising across the country. They are not. Hospitalisations for “assault by sharp object”, one of the most reliable indicators of violent crime, have fallen by a third in England since 2019. Last year homicides fell to a 50-year low. Social media’s doomsterism goes some way to explaining this disconnect, as do spikes in shoplifting and phone snatching. A less appreciated reason is that the geography of violent crime is changing. The urban centres historically associated with violence have achieved impressive reductions over the past decade. Rates have fallen much more slowly in the counties. In some they have increased. Consider Birmingham, London and Manchester. In the year to March 2018, the start of Britain’s knife-crime epidemic, these three cities accounted for 47% of the country’s knife-related homicides and attempted murders. In the year ending March 2026 this was down to 36%. In each city, homicides have fallen by more than 30% from their peak. Progress has been much slower in places like Suffolk (down by 18%), Hampshire (14%), Nottinghamshire (13%) and Cambridgeshire (up 23%). Hospitalisations for “assault by sharp object” show a similar pattern. Most police forces have data only up to the year ending March 2025. Look at a

two-year rolling average and London’s is down by 28% from the peak years of 2018 and 2019. Much more modest falls have taken place in Staffordshire (down by 14%), Durham (7%), Devon and Cornwall (5%) and Hertfordshire (5%). In Sussex there has not been any drop at all (see chart). Hospitalisation rates are growing fastest, albeit from a low base, in Cambridgeshire and Bedfordshire—leafy, suburban communities that last year suffered increases of 60% and 50%, respectively. Middlesbrough, a poor town but not one that has a long history of severe street violence, is recording more sharp-object hospitalisations than it did during Britain’s peak years. Following the deaths of two police officers and seven other people, and growing public disorder, it has become the site of an organised-crime investigation. Even within London, police-recorded violence is growing fastest in boroughs such as Hillingdon (up by 9% last year) and Kingston upon Thames (up by 13%), which are relatively affluent areas on the outskirts. Overall the upsurge of the 2010s is proving most resilient outside the urban centres usually associated with violent crime. This is largely the result of changes in the structure of Britain’s drugs market. Violent crime in Britain is closely linked to drug trafficking. This is as true in the counties as it is in cities. A study published in 2021 looking at six years’ worth of air-ambulance call-outs in Kent, for example, found that instances of “penetrating trauma” tend to occur along drug-trafficking routes. These “county lines” emerged in the late 2010s as the advent of the dark web (used more for wholesale drug purchases than retail), together with cuts in police numbers, led to a proliferation of drug gangs in urban centres. Competition between them was the main cause of Britain’s knife-crime surge in the late 2010s. It also brought more violence to the counties, as gangs looked for less crowded markets outside the cities. They built a business model using vulnerable children as mules—ferrying deliveries from urban gangs to rural addicts. Knives are a way to protect yourself, and your product, from rivals who would take it. Thankfully most areas are recording less violence than they did during this first wave of expansion. But rural violence is proving sticky because such areas remain the most profitable route to growth for drug-dealing groups. In

2020 a Home Office review found that the levelling-off of urban drug use was driving gangs towards new markets around towns and universities. According to annual threat assessments, the number of county lines known to the authorities has increased from 720 in 2017 to more than 6,500 today. The dealers have also expanded their product lines. While the original county-lines gangs dealt mainly in crack and heroin, they now also traffic in cannabis, powdered cocaine, ketamine and prescription drugs. Increased competition in rural areas has created a market based on customer service. Above all that means speedy deliveries. In many British towns it is now possible to have drugs delivered within an hour—think Amazon Prime for amphetamines. That is a difficult service for a business based in London to provide for customers in Margate. Supply lines have had to adapt. “The classic county-lines model of sending your boys down on the train has gone,” explains Simon Harding, a criminologist. “It’s much easier to set up a local hub and deal from there.” The result is that drug gangs are increasingly indigenous to rural areas, dealing from local properties and recruiting local children. The number of “internal lines” (those operating within rather than between counties) known to the police trebled between 2022 and 2025. The share of lines originating in “task-force areas” (covering the traditional hotspots) fell from 70% to 50%. It is a shift the government appears unprepared for. The Knife Crime Action Plan, released at the start of April, says a lot of the right things. But it also adopts an outdated definition of the county-lines model—promising to empower the British Transport Police to disrupt the train networks used to move drugs from cities to towns, and to boost funding to County Lines Taskforces. This targets a business model that is already changing. When so much violence is perpetrated by vulnerable young people recruited by predatory organised criminals, prevention is a public-health problem as much as a policing one. In the traditional hotbeds of knife violence, local experience with gangs has produced a certain amount of understanding of criminal practices, from clued-up family members to streetwise youth workers. Rural areas lack that kind of exposure. Many are used to seeing knife crime as an urban, even a racial, problem best solved by tougher

policing. “That is a very difficult mindset to get out of,” admits Niven Rennie, a former police officer who served as director of the Scottish Violence Reduction Unit. “But once you understand it, you don’t go back.” ■ This article was downloaded by zlibrary from https://www.economist.com/britain/2026/09/03/the-changing-geography-of-violent- crime-in-britain

Britain · Britain | Sharper thinking

London’s approach to knife crime is working Sadiq Khan has mainstreamed a public-health approach that was previously fringe Sep 3rd 2026 London is known for many things. Among the least flattering is its reputation as a hotbed for knife crime. Last year Mexico, a country at war with drug cartels, updated its travel guidance to warn about knife assaults in Britain’s capital. According to Donald Trump, Londoners live in fear of being “stabbed in the ass”. This was never really true. For six of the past eight years, New Yorkers have been more likely to be stabbed to death than Londoners (and they have been at least ten times as likely to be killed by other means). That doesn’t mean the reputation was a complete fabrication. Knife crime rose dramatically in Britain from 2017, especially among teenagers. In the year to March 2018

more than 280 people were stabbed to death in England and Wales, up from the previous five-year average of just over 200 a year. London, the core of the crisis, accounted for 108 of those homicides (compared with 62 deadly stabbings in New York that year). Since then rates of violence have declined precipitously. Hospitalisations for “assault by sharp object” have fallen by a third in London since their peak. Knife-related homicides have shrunk by a half. Last year teenage homicides in the capital fell to their joint lowest level (similar to 2012) in almost 30 years. In 2025 you were twice as likely to be stabbed to death in New York as in London. Thank Sadiq Khan. Right-wingers like to blame London’s Labour mayor for the capital’s imagined lawlessness. In fact Lord Khan introduced England to a knife-crime strategy that appears to be working. It has since spread beyond London. As English politicians scrambled for answers during the 2017-19 “epidemic”, Lord Khan looked to Scotland. In the previous decade Glasgow, once labelled Europe’s murder capital, had achieved impressive reductions in violent crime. One reason was the roll-out of the Scottish Violence Reduction Unit (VRU), which aims to prevent violent crime by bringing the police, schools, hospitals and sports clubs together to identify at-risk children and direct them away from crime. Between 2008 and 2018 Scotland’s VRUs were credited with bringing about a 38% fall in homicides and a 43% drop in attempted murders and serious assaults—many of them knife-related. Lord Khan announced England’s first VRU in London in 2018. Today there are 20 such units across England and Wales, covering areas that account for 80% of all knife crime. A recent Home Office review found that England’s VRUs caused a 12% fall, since 2019, in hospital admissions for violent assault among the under-25s. That is modest compared with Glasgow, but the Home Office looked only at the national average. Violent crime has fallen most in cities like London— dense urban areas where the model is easiest to implement.

There are caveats. Alcohol use, a big factor in violent crime, has dropped across the country, too. Scotland’s success, which occurred around the same time as changes to licensing laws, cannot be put down just to its VRU. Nor can London’s (between mid-2020 and mid-2024 London lost 29% of its nightclubs). It also takes time to work out what produces the best results in a given area. Scotland did well by placing youth workers in accident-and- emergency departments to reach children with violence-related injuries. VRUs in England and Wales, still in an earlier stage, are spending a lot on interventions, such as school visits, that show little evidence of working. The overarching logic, however, is sound. A 2023 study by the Youth Endowment Fund, a charity, found that having two or more adverse childhood experiences increases the risk of gang involvement by 61%. In Britain today violent crime is largely driven by organised-crime groups relying on vulnerable young people to traffic drugs. That is different from early-2000s Glasgow, where territorial street gangs were much more interested in recreational violence and turf wars than in drug trafficking. But in either case VRUs can help restrict the labour market available to exploitative gangs. Scotland’s success, according to Iain Brennan, a criminologist, was not just to adopt the model but to change the hearts and minds of all involved. “It’s the philosophy of violence reduction, of changing the mindset that is the most important.” Lord Khan is often ridiculed for what can appear a fluffy approach, emphasising the importance of youth clubs and keeping troublesome children at school. But his soft approach is having hard effects. ■ This article was downloaded by zlibrary from https://www.economist.com/britain/2026/09/03/londons-approach-to-knife-crime-is- working